Saturday 14 May 2016

Week 25: Applied Practice in Context


Activity 1: My community of practice

Who am I?

The final module, Applied Practice in Context, calls for us to keep a reflective journal. Boud et al (1985) defined reflective practice as “a generic term for those intellectual and affective activities in which individuals engage to explore their experiences in order to lead a new understanding and appreciation”. Talking to other colleagues, we often do carry out this reflective practice in our heads without too much overthinking, a typical reflection might be - we tried a new activity in the classroom and it didn't work. We then reflect upon why didn't it work? and what could we do next time to increase the likelihood of it being successful or do we need to do something totally new?

At the beginning of this study I started a Blog of my Mindlab journey but got so involved in applying my learning into the classroom that my time seemed to get diverted from my blog to enabling my students to keep their own classroom blog. As well as other collaborative and digital technologies ideas that have stemmed from this study. 

In hindsight, or should I say ‘upon reflection’ it seems a pity I wasn’t able to keep my blog going throughout the course as it has been an amazing learning adventure, but balance is the key, and so when something had to go, the blog was one of the ‘chosen ones’. At times, the workload of this course has totally overwhelmed me and I have had to give up precious family time to keep on top of the coursework, assignments and new classroom initiatives. Time and memories and moments that I can never get back. I often reflect on this, and it makes me feel rather sad, that I have had to choose ‘school work and study’ over spending time with my husband, son and family and friends.

Please don’t misunderstand me, I am absolutely passionate about my role as an ‘educator’ and love working in such an interesting and engaging environment. But teaching seems far more that a 9 to 5 job and sometimes it seems to be greedy and it doesn’t seems to matter how much you put in, it just never seems to be enough. I love the kids, variety and challenges that teaching offers me, but on the flip side, I can see why many teachers burn themselves out and I wonder if we will ever take a leaf out of other countries educational system, like Finland, and how things could look if we did. To have more time to do your best for the students, not to have to rush so much or have an ever growing and never ending list of things that need doing, is something that I am sure most teachers can only dream of.  

So who I am? I am a wife, mother, family member, friend, colleague and teacher. I am probably a lot of other things as well, but these are probably my biggest ‘who am I’ things at this time in my life. I have been teaching for 14 years and I qualified as a secondary Science teacher in Aberystwyth, Wales. At present I teach Junior Science and Senior Agriculture and Horticulture at a rural year 7-13 College. Although the way houses are starting to pop up around us I am not sure how much longer we will be rural for.

What is Communities of Practice?

Etienne Wenger first coined the concept of “communities of practice”, which are defined as “groups of people who share a concern or a passion or about a topic, and who deepen their knowledge and expertise in this area by interaction on an ongoing basis” (Wenger, McDermott & Snyder, 2002, p.4). Etienne et al (2015) explain how Communities of practice are formed by people who engage in a process of collective learning in a shared domain or human endeavour. It is not a new practice, but through understanding it is now acknowledged that by spending time within this practice, improvements can be achieved in your own professional practices. 

There are 3 key characteristics that contribute to meaningful and successful communities of practice:
1.    The shared Domain of interest.
2.    The Community in which people interact and learn from each other.
3.    The Practice - Members of the community of practice are practitioners. They develop a shared repertoire of resources. For example, experiences, stories, tools, ways of addressing recurring problems.

What are my professional communities of practice?

What is the purpose and function of my practice? In what ways do I contribute to the community of my practice?

My purpose and function of my practice is to care about the well-being of my students and to help students learn. To provide a safe environment for them to be in and to provide suitable learning programs, that are suited to their individual requirement as well as meeting the requirements of the school. 

My own professional learning community at present includes the Mindlab discussion groups I have become part of whilst partaking in this course. At school all teachers are involved in whole-school meetings and PD sessions as well as smaller department group meetings. During these meetings I take on different roles, such as the learner, mentor, coach and leader. Often, I am asked by colleagues to share ideas, tools and experiences I have gained from the different initiatives I have been trialling in my classrooms.


I often engage in professional discussions in smaller group settings. Sometimes individual teachers will seek my advice during meetings and also I may spend time in non-teaching time with other staff discussing ideas and issues related to our teaching practices. I often provide support and advice when asked by other teachers. I am president of HATA (Horticulture and Agriculture Teachers Association) and this often provides subject-related discussions and professional development that I would not be exposed to at where I work. I am a member of many professional Facebook groups, often related to leadership, education, Science and Agriculture. I am also involved in Primary Industry groups, which I work with to provide links between the students and the Agriculture Industry. I haven't really managed to get a handle on twitter, although I have joined, but it's probably an area that I could do with a little more help, although again, I have a concern of it impeding on my 'home' time, but maybe I just need to find strategies to manage it so that that doesn't happen...or maybe I already have?

What is my specialist area of practice? How does my specialist area of practice relate to the broader professional context?

I am teacher in-charge of my subject, Rural Sciences, and am working hard to evolve all of my programs to provide learning experiences that are engaging, relevant and authentic and better suited to my individual students needs. I have always been keen to offer students hand-on, student-led and fun learning environments but my understanding and knowledge of how to do so effectively has been deepened this year. As has my knowledge and understanding of implementing the use of digital technology into the classroom. This has been mostly due to taking part in the Mindlab Post-Graduate course. 

I also spend time trying to build positive relationships with my students and building links within the community, which will benefit the students learning and the relationship they have in the community now, and in the future. I am keen to try to breakdown silos between subject areas and often approach, share and listen to ideas and request of how we could move forward in this direction. I am also interested in making use of digital technology in the classroom to improve student learning and key competency skills. I also have an interest in how future NZQA formal examinations will change as we start to make more use of digital technology.

References
Boud, D., Keogh, R., & Walker, D. (1985). Reflection: Turning experience into learning. London: Kogan Page.

Dawson, P (2012) Reflective Practice. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r1aYWbLj0U8
Introduction to communities of practice: A brief overview of the concept and its uses
http://wenger-trayner.com/introduction-to-communities-of-practice/

Wenger, E., McDermott, R., & Snyder, W. M. (2002). Cultivating communities of practice: A guide to managing knowledge. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.

12 comments:

  1. I completely agree and empathize with your comments. I too, feel like butter spread thin upon toast in this course. I love my job, and love the innovation that Mindlab brings. For the APC, I am trying to work smarter. For my Community of Practice, I am going to use my Professional Learning Group at school in the hope that I can provide deeper insight by concentrating on "one thing", rather than having several different things going on at the same time. The distractions of Mindlab are great, however, I really feel that I need to concentrate on one thing or risk coming out with little bits of everything and lots of nothing...if you know what I mean. Thanks for your honesty inyour blog, a lot of people probably feel the same way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Brigitte, Thank you for commenting on my Blog. Working smarter sounds like a great idea.. I got a DVD out of the unitec library called "never work harder than your students" or something promising like that... I still haven't had time to look at it yet! ha. The idea of just focusing on one thing is a good one and maybe I should try to do that with all the different innovations I have learnt and want to try out in my classroom.

      Delete
  2. It is always a challenge to juggle the load that is education - I have neglected my own blog during my Mindlab journey and I find I am a little more 'thinly spread' as Brigitte has quite correctly surmised, than usual. Family time is precious and all I can suggest is to see if you can find something you can 'park' during the journey, so that family time is not the thing parked! On the plus side, nearly there, and the learning you take with you from this journey will have an impact on your practice for the rest of your career. So in some respects, short term sacrifice for long term rewards!
    nb: I do like how you term education as 'greedy' - all I can picture now is a fat little pig sucking in more and more....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Principally Mused,
      Sorry I am not sure of your real name. Thanks for your suggestion of finding things to 'park'... it made me remember that we are often our harshest critic and we forget to be kind to ourselves and remember we are doing our best. Doing this course has been amazing and I am sure both myself and my students will benefit from it for years to come. It has been great to meet like-minded, positive and supportive people and to have such fun learning during the 'meet' sessions. I think it would of been great to have had another teacher from my school doing it with me so I had another to share and bounce ideas and energy off of. I don't really get many comments back when I share ideas, resources that have surfaced from doing the Mindlab course and some are even quite critical and negative about it all, which is not so much fun. Now you have me thinking of fat little pigs :)

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  3. Hi Alison, it was great to read your blog. It is always reassuring to find others that are passionate about education in science. I have found the mind lab programme fantastic. In that it has challenged my learning and the way I set up my classroom and collaborate with my students. It has been great to move from learning content to giving the students the freedom to direct their own learning and develop their problem solving skills. There are so many ideas that I want to try in my classroom but I often find myself conflicted between setting up and developing these initiatives and getting my mind lab assignments done. Blogging is a great tool for reflective practice but I have had to let this slide as I juggle everything. My children are still young so my husband has also had to put in extra time looking after them on what would normally be family outings so I can get my assignments handed in. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. If you do come across any strategies for managing to keeping up with everything, particularly multiple classroom blogs and your own online communities (twitter etc) let me know. I am find if I manage one the others go. Great to hear your thoughts and that others out there are keen to break down the subject silos. Anne��

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Anne, thank you for commenting on my blog. Like you, I have loved being able try new student programs that are less content driven and giving students ownership as to the direction we take. I was wondering if you taught near me, I would love to visit other schools to see what they have happening and I am keen to hear about initiatives you have tried with your students? My one timesaver?... I always take work to do in the car, whilst my husband drives :) I can do some professional reading or even mark a class load of books/tests etc in this time, and because I can't go anywhere I seem to get it done a lot quicker that when I can go off wandering onto other jobs :)

      Delete
  4. Hi Alison, thanks for sharing your blog and your feelings. I too have found myself on a roller coaster with this course, one I've wanted to get off a few times I must say! Your comments regarding family and workload resonate with me as I'm sure they do with many. As we enter the final phase of the course however, I finding myself feeling a lot more positive about the experience and the learning that it has pushed me to do. I'm really proud of my Lit Review (regardless of the mark) and I've found myself being able to contribute to and engage meaningfully in many discussions pertaining to pedagogy, digital tools, collaboration and much more. For myself as a new teacher (PRT 2) it has helped form my identity as I evolve in my new career. Undoubtedly one of the best aspects has been meeting new people and making some great friends such as yourself! I look forward to the next 8 weeks as document the last leg of our journey. Thanks again.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Thanks for sharing your blog. It has been an excellent learning journey connecting and sharing with you. I am lucky enough to be in your "external community of practice" through Mindlab.
    I really like you comment about the "purpose and function of your practice is to care about the well-being of my students and to help students learn. To provide a safe environment for them to be in and to provide suitable learning programs, that are suited to their individual requirement as well as meeting the requirements of the school."
    Your learners have given you a supportive community to belong to.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Joyce, thank you for writing on my blog. It has been great meeting, sharing and working with you on this course. I have really enjoyed listening to the innovations you have tried and implemented into your learning area and it has inspired me to try new ideas that have spring boarded from our discussions and learning sessions.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Teenaa koe Alison. Communities of practice are very new to me and although I was resistance and 'fearful' of being a part of one (now many) I have found the benefits outweigh any prior objections. My main concern was that as a Maaori - we do a lot of our communicating following tikanga - kanohi ki te kanohi - or face to face. The apprehension to talk to 'strangers' people I had not previously shared breath with was daunting. I like to reflect on my resistance and remind myself that when I introduce new things to my students in my class that their resistance is so similar to mine. How do I alleviate this??? Making sure they know they are at the center of everything I plan, create and do. I think your comment that said 'My purpose and function of my practice is to care about the well-being of my students and to help students learn' is very important to me too. I was wondering how you collect evidence or data from students to see if they feel cared for. I have tried collecting student voice in video form. I found that the answers the kids said were all very 'cheerful' - and I thought, hmmm that does not really help me refine my teaching as inquiry. I often think about finding a way to get critical feedback from the students - as I know they can critically analyse things in the work. I am open to any ideas. Thanks

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi There Principally Mused,

      Love the name by the way. I can see that you are a really passionate educator and bring a lot to your Community of Practice. I am a teacher at the Tertiary level and teach business. Unfortunately I haven't been in high school since the 90's. Anyway I am guessing that 'Rural Sciences' is what we used to call 'Agriculture'. Being from a rural farming background, I can remember thinking back in Agriculture class just how abstract it was from how a real farm worked. When you define your practice, I am curious how you try to bridge the social and physical distance that you and your students have with Rural New Zealand farmers. Do students in your school get the opportunity to talk with farmers? Do farmers have any input into the curriculum at the school level? I found when thinking about my own Community of Practice, being a tertiary lecturer in the Business PTE sector, where 100% of my students are international and are on pathway to permanent residency. I found it interesting to redefine my identity, to include further stakeholders such as concerned citizens of New Zealand. I now prefer to think of myself as a Steward of Quality Immigration.

      Delete